Showing posts with label Stead.Rebecca. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stead.Rebecca. Show all posts

Sunday, December 16, 2012

Liar and Spy

by Rebecca Stead
December 16, 2012

This has been getting some good review and has been on several end-of-the-year "best of" lists.  Rebecca Stead won the 2010 Newbery Medal for When You Reach Me   I'm not sure that she'll win again this year, but I actually liked Liar and Spy much better than When You Reach Me.

Georges (named after Seurat) and his parents have just moved into an apartment building in Brooklyn. It's a big change because they had been living in a house, but when Georges' dad loses his job, they must downsize and his mother has to spend more time at the hospital where she is a nurse.

On the day they move in Georges meets an unusual boy named Safer and his sister Candy when he accepts an invitation to attend a Spy Club. Safer teaches Georges how to be a spy and they begin trying to figure out what the mysterious Mr X from the fifth floor is up to.

As with  When You Reach Me, the author writes about friendships, school and family.  Georges has to deal with bullies, his new home, the sometimes exasperating Safer and his parents' absence. Dad is working hard to gain new clients for his design business and Mom is always at the hospital.

Liar and Spy is appearing in  everybody's 2013 Newbery predictions, but I have a feeling about the book Wonder by R.J. Palacio.  I'd like to read more of the possible contenders before January 28th when the ALA Youth Media Awards are announced.


Friday, March 5, 2010

When You Reach Me

by Rebecca Stead
Finished March 2, 2010

This book won the 2010 Newbery Medal. I had noticed it a few months before the medal was announced. It looked good, but I didn't read it, obviously, until afterwards.
I enjoyed it but have no opinion on its worthiness to win a Newbery. I'd hate to be on the committee that determines that award. I just wouldn't know how to pick one winner from among hundreds of books published in a single year.
The story is about twelve-year-old Miranda and her friendships and family relationships. I would have liked this story when I was ten, eleven, twelve. It's one of the genre tht I liked back then - what I call "school stories." Miranda is best friends with Sal. That relationship is broken when Sal gets punched in the stomach, for no reason, by another kid from their school.
Miranda must make new friendships and she finds just that with Amanda and Colin. They strenghten their bonds when they all take lunch-time jobs at Jimmy's sandwhich shop.
Meanwhile, Miranda's mother is practicing for an appearance on the $20,000 Pyramid game show (this book is set in 1979). I was thrown for a loop when a mysterious, science-fiction element pops into the story. Miranda keeps finding strange, anonymous notes that seem to predict the future. The book turns from just a "school story" into a science-fiction story. I would have liked that when I was ten, eleven and twelve, too.
In all, I liked this book but it didn't wow me. I wish she had dropped the sci-fi theme and just concentrated on the relationships between her many great characters.